SEARCH 
 
• EXCLUSIVE THEATER DISCOUNTS
• MONTHLY GIVEAWAYS
  SIGN UP FOR FREE
  
 
Peter Filichia's Diary at TheaterMania.com
Peter Filichia's Diary
January 7, 2009

Yes, we learned long ago that a hundred million miracles are happ’ning ev’ry day. But would we have ever imagined that one of them would be that the 1961 film of Flower Drum Song would make the National Film Registry’s list of preserved films?

Sure, Flower Drum Song definitely means well. Wang Chi Yang is a Chinese immigrant now living in San Francisco, but he’s still Chinese through-and-through. He has two sons: The younger is Wang San, a teenager who has been easily assimilated into American life. The older son, Wang Ta, is pulled between old Chinese traditions and the new-fangled United States. The book, on which Oscar Hammerstein II collaborated with Joseph Fields, comes to a nice conclusion that there is worth in both cultures. Along the way, there are some catchy Richard Rodgers melodies, too.

Still, Flower Drum Song lacks the importance of the Big Five R&H classics, for it is a “mere” musical comedy. Hugh Fordin, in his marvelous biography of Oscar Hammerstein, quotes the author’s opinion of his 1958 musical: “I’ve had some unlucky flops in my life. I’ve had some plays that deserved to run better than they did. And then I’ve had some well-deserved hits. But this is the first lucky hit I’ve ever had.”

Nevertheless, Flower Drum Song becomes the third Rodgers & Hammerstein to make the National Film Registry list that’s annually added 25 titles since it was founded in 1988. The first was – no surprise – The Sound of Music in 2001. Oklahoma! followed just last year. Fine, but would you have guessed that Flower Drum Song – the least successful of the team’s six hits – would have been next? Sure, South Pacific and Carousel have their problems and detractors, but many might have expected The King and I to be the third R&H chosen, if another was to be chosen at all.

One of the original purposes of the registry was to ensure that these films would not be butchered when aired on network TV; that’s why, if you catch The Sound of Music in one of its holiday airings, it often ends at an odd time, beyond the hour or half-hour mark – because nothing has been cut. If that policy remains in place now and forever, any network that shows Flower Drum Song will give its audience such lines as “If I cross her, she’ll cut me off without a fried noodle,” “Don’t take any wooden chopsticks,” “She’s built like a Ming vase,” and “I never fully approved of the old custom of drowning daughters.” There’s also “I got another kumquat in the face,” which is not to be confused with, “The old man sure left you with egg foo yung on your face.” Still, the least politically correct line is what an on-stage comic says after he’s delivered a joke that’s bombed: “Back to the laundry.” Under these circumstances, the observation that Wang Chi Yang says to Wang San could double as a criticism of the script itself: “You have an unfortunate way of expressing yourself.”

The Registry asks that every musical number be sacrosanct, too. That not only means, “Dong-dong, you’re in Hong Kong” must be retained, but also the 13 seconds where Wang San and Linda, Wang Ta’s girlfriend, sing a snippet that goes, “You be the rock, I’ll be the roll; you be the soup, I’ll be the bowl; you be the furnace; I’ll be the coal.” Later, in “Chop Suey,” Bobby Darin and Sandra Dee are both mentioned. The two saw their marriage dissolve after less than seven years, but now they’ll probably be forever linked through the protected film version of Flower Drum Song.

Interesting, isn’t it, that the National Film Registry asks that neither a word nor a frame of the Flower Drum Song film be changed, while The Rodgers & Hammerstein Organization felt that the original stage play could be extensively revised, and hired David Henry Hwang to do it?

So why was Flower Drum Song chosen by the National Film Registry while The King and I was not? The answer is apparently that the latter film cast the respective roles of Tuptim, Lady Thiang, Lun Tha and the Kralahome with Rita Moreno, Terry Saunders, Carlos Rivas and Martin Benson: Not an Asian among them. Yul Brynner, who of course played the King, was Asian in that he was born in the part of Russia that is located in Asia. Nevertheless, he wasn’t quite Siamese, if you please.

But as the citation for Flower Drum Song says, this film “marked the first Hollywood studio film featuring performances by a mostly Asian cast, a break from past practice of casting white actors made up to appear Asian. Starring prominent Asian-American actors Nancy Kwan and James Shigeta, this milestone film presented an enduring three-dimensional portrait of Asian America as well as a welcomed, non-clichéd portrait of Chinatown beyond the usual exotic tourist façades.” So while we’re inclined to think of the National Film Registry’s choices are Great Movies, that’s not what the organization is looking for: It wants to recognize those films that are “culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant.”

And though Juanita Hall (who appeared in the stage show as well) was actually African-American, two important Flower Drum Song roles that were played by Caucasians on stage were on film portrayed by Asian-Americans: 1) Ed Kenney, the original Wang Ta, was replaced by Shigeta. 2) In the role of his romantic rival Sammy Fong, Larry Storch was originally cast, though by the time the show opened in New York, the equally Caucasian Larry Blyden had succeeded him. On film, Japanese actor Jack Soo got his big break with the role.

Am I complaining about Flower Drum Song’s being chosen? I really can’t, for in my life, the film turned out to be “culturally significant,” too.

Here’s why: In 1961, when I was 15, I was just becoming aware of this wonderful thing called The Broadway Musical, so the moment Flower Drum Song came to the RKO Keith Memorial in downtown Boston, I rushed there and sat in the very first row. A few minutes after the film began, I heard two men settle in directly behind me in the second row. And for the next two-plus hours, I noticed that every time I laughed at a line, these two guys laughed just as hard; when I merely chuckled, they merely chuckled, too. Almost always, we started and stopped laughing to the precise second. We were all on the same page with this one, true soul-mates in humor.

The second the film ended, I spun around in my seat to say, “Wasn’t that great?!” – and was surprised to see that the two guys were African-American. Understand that I came from a lily-white suburb where there were simply no black people at all. I’d never met one. I’d never spoken to one. And while the nuns at the Catholic schools I’d attended had always taught us that “Everyone is the same,” this is where I learned it was true. And wouldn’t Oscar Hammerstein, of all people, have been utterly pleased to see that his lucky hit had carefully taught me this lesson? Wouldn’t he have also loved the irony that a Caucasian-American and African-Americans were responding to a story about Asian-Americans?

Coda: A week or so later, I was sitting in class, and as soon as school ended, Margaret Trometer came up to me to say she’d seen Flower Drum Song. My reputation as a lover of Broadway musicals was already spreading, so Margaret knew I’d give an eager ear to her opinions. So, while our teacher Sister Marillac was collecting her papers and getting ready to return to the convent, she overheard Margaret gush about this story of an Asian family in conflict.

And after Margaret said, “And, oh, that James Shigeta! Isn’t he handsome?” Sister Marillac’s eyes widened as she screeched, “Handsome? A Chinaman?!?!”

You may e-mail Peter at pfilichia@aol.com


12:01 AM | Peter Filichia

Peter Filichia's Diary is written and edited by Peter Filichia, and updated every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. TheaterMania.com acts solely as host and as such shall not be deemed to endorse, recommend, approve and/or guarantee any events, facts, views, advice and/or information contained therein.
January 5, 2009

Next Sunday at 11 o’clock – in the morning, mind you – will be “My Time of Day” for Frank Loesser. It should also be a great time of day for those who attend Sean Hartley’s Broadway Playhouse at Merkin Concert Hall, where Loesser’s career will be unveiled to new audiences.

For Broadway Playhouse isn’t for octogenarians who saw the original Where’s Charley? in 1948 or even the baby-boomers who caught the 1976 black revival of Guys and Dolls. Broadway Playhouse, as that second word implies, is for kids. They can attend alone or with their parents and learn about musical theater.

Hartley is the director of the theater wing for the Kaufman Center, which operates Merkin Concert Hall at 129 West 67th St. He hosts each event, too, but let’s him tell you what’s he’s been doing and what he’s planning.

Sean Hartley: When I came here in 1989 as an assistant in the education department, I thought we could start a classical musical series for children -- and soon found that there are a lot of those around town. But nobody was doing anything to get kids interested in my main interest, musical theater.

Peter Filichia: How did it become your main interest?

SH: When I was a kid, my father was always playing original cast albums – My Fair Lady and Oklahoma! When I found out that stories went along with these wonderful songs, I was utterly intrigued. So I thought that maybe other kids could get interested in musicals if they were introduced to the stories as well as the music. I also figured that lots of parents who may not even like classical music take their kids to classical music concerts because they think “it’s good for them” – but many more parents genuinely love musical theater and would love the chance to share that with their kids. So three times a year, we provide an experience for families that introduce kids to this in a child-centered way. The kids leave knowing that name of one writer, at least one show that the writer wrote, and one song, which we teach them. So last year, we introduced them to Sheldon Harnick and gave them a little bit of Fiddler. I’m hoping the kids left the show saying to their parents, “Oh, can we see the whole thing someday?”

PF: Do you worry that when you bring out an author who’s of an advanced age that the kids immediately turn off, because they can’t relate to that old man up there?

SH: I don’t think that kids necessarily dislike people for being old, but it is true that they tend to be focused on their peers. So we have young performers. Jason Robinson is our comic male; Kathryn Markey our character woman; Steve Pacek is our romantic lead and Erica Schroeder our sopranoey ingénue.

PF: Speaking of sopranos, I’ve found that young people who are exposed to musical theater find listening to sopranos very off-putting.

SH: Maybe that’s true because they haven’t heard much of it in their daily lives. Oh, they hear an aggravated high belt, but that’s something else. I’ll admit that soprano singing is something they think of as opera. But almost every good choral director cultivates a head sound, and kids don’t find it that hard to do, so we offer it.

PF: Tell me about the Loesser program that you’re doing this Sunday.

SH: An excellent writer named Bob Kolsby and I did the script. It starts with five or 10 minutes on the history of Frank Loesser himself. Then our performers do some songs he did for Hollywood before he came to Broadway. Then they do a medley of Where’s Charley, The Most Happy Fella, and How to Succeed before we center on Guys and Dolls.

PF: No Greenwillow?

SH: No, I thought about “Never Will I Marry,” but, great song though it is, I decided against it. We may do something from Hans Christian Andersen, too, and are trying to decide between “The Ugly Duckling” and “The Emperor’s New Clothes.” But it’ll mostly be Guys and Dolls. We’ll invite boys in the audience to come up and play gamblers, while the girls will have the chance to be missionaries and nightclub entertainers. Some kids will win prizes -- CDs or DVDs of some of the material they hear.

PF: You may have had Sheldon Harnick in attendance, but you can’t hope for Frank Loesser to show.

SH: Well, you never know who’s going to be there; when we did Rodgers and Hammerstein, an actress who played one of the king’s wives in The King and I was in the audience, and had a few things to say. But, no, we don’t expect Frank Loesser. That’s why we like to do at least one show a year that can feature a writer who’s alive. Besides, I don’t want all our shows to feature music that’s 50 years old, or that we’re just thought of as worshipping the past. So on April 5, we’ll do Ahrens and Flaherty, and they’ll be on stage with us to talk.

PF: And Ragtime will be the show on which you center?

SH: No, I’m not going to be explaining why a young woman buried her child in the backyard and why a young man becomes a terrorist who gets shot. No, I’m going with Seussical.

PF: Amazing, isn’t it, how that show roses from the ashes of its Broadway debacle to become one of the most household-name titles of the past decade.

SH: I find Seussical both modest and inventive. We’ll center on the Horton story, which kids know.

PF: And in between Loesser and Ahrens and Flaherty?

SH: We’ll do Jerry Herman on Sunday, February 1st. He wasn’t available, but his works certainly are. Of course we’ll d something from Dolly and Mame, but I may include something from Dear World, which I greatly admire. One day I’d love to do a genuine Dear World concert where a different performer would take each of Aurelia’s songs: Karen Akers doing one, Donna Murphy doing another ...

PF: In doing Broadway Playhouse, have you run into any artistic roadblocks?

SH: I did when we did Cole Porter, whom I wanted to do because he was such an extraordinary writer. Then I found that so many of his songs involve double entendres, or have a sophisticated spin on something that kids wouldn’t get. I was no different when I was their age. I heard “My Heart Belongs to Daddy,” and not until years later did I learn that Mary Martin wasn’t talking about loving her father. So while we wound up giving the kids “You’re the Top” and the gangsters in Kiss Me, Kate, the sing-along song we wound up teaching them was the song Porter wrote while he was at Yale: “Bulldog, Bulldog, Bow-Wow-Wow.”

PF: How much outreach do you do?

SH: The Monday after our Sunday performances, we do a 10:15 matinee for school groups. Many people from the board of Ed have come and have highly recommended it.

PF: Has all this led to any other programs?

SH: Yes, we have a summer musical theater workshop each July. Each group of 15 kids writes and works on an original musical. What helps is that all the music directors are musical theater writers and all the directors are script writers, too. We create seven new musicals, from 10 to 30 minutes long.

PF: And maybe some day, one of those kids will write a show and be featured at a Broadway Playhouse.

SH: Sounds good to me!

Admission to each Broadway Playhouse is $20, but three-event subscriptions are available for $45. Call Faye Menken Schneier at 212-501-3357.

You may e-mail Peter at pfilichia@aol.com

 

12:01 AM | Peter Filichia

Peter Filichia's Diary is written and edited by Peter Filichia, and updated every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. TheaterMania.com acts solely as host and as such shall not be deemed to endorse, recommend, approve and/or guarantee any events, facts, views, advice and/or information contained therein.

search

Recent entries
The Hundreth Millionth Miracle
(07 Jan 2009 00:01:00)
Why We'll Never Beat Sports
(02 Jan 2009 00:01:00)
December Leftovers
(31 Dec 2008 00:01:00)
Mordden and The Real Dimitri Weismann
(29 Dec 2008 00:01:00)
You ARE That Smart
(26 Dec 2008 00:01:00)
Your Stage-to-Screen Picks
(24 Dec 2008 00:01:00)
Steppin' to the Bad Seed
(22 Dec 2008 00:01:00)

FEED
[RSS][ATOM] All
[RSS][ATOM] Peter Filichia's Diary

admin
RSS Feed
By providing information about entertainment and cultural events on this site, TheaterMania.com shall not be deemed to endorse,
recommend, approve and/or guarantee such events, or any facts, views, advice and/or information contained therein.
©1999-2009 TheaterMania Inc. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy

Click here for a current list of Broadway shows and Broadway ticket discounts.